🔎 1. Look for outcomes, not responsibilities
“Managed recruitment lifecycle” sounds solid.
But look for what changed because they were there. Strong profiles show impact like:
• Reduced time-to-fill
• Increased retention
• Improved process efficiency
• Closed hard-to-fill roles under pressure
Outcomes are harder to inflate than duties.
🔎 2. Separate ownership from participation
Many candidates speak in “we.”
Strong candidates can clearly explain:
“What exactly did you handle?”
If they can’t isolate their contribution, you may be looking at assisted experience, not owned experience.
🔎 3. Probe decision-making
Real experience shows up in trade-offs.
Ask:
“What would you have done differently?”
“What was the toughest call you had to make?”
Depth lives in reflection. Inflation lives in generalities.
🔎 4. Ask about friction
Every real role has problems.
“What was the hardest part of that project?”
If the answer sounds effortless, it probably wasn’t real.
Specific struggle stories reveal genuine exposure